The standard way into either city used to be a fast train from Madrid. Since the collision at Urda on 28 October, which killed more than 60 people, high-speed services between Madrid and Andalusia have been suspended, with no reopening date and Renfe sales blocked until December. For the moment you will arrive some other way, and that turns out to be a good test, because how these two cities receive you is much like how they treat you after a year.
Coming in by air
Seville wins this outright. Its airport handled about nine million passengers in 2024, with Ryanair and Vueling based there and easyJet, Lufthansa, British Airways and Turkish flying in. Dublin, Manchester, Frankfurt, Istanbul, even Marrakesh are direct. You walk out to the Airport Express bus, which runs from about 04:30 until nearly 01:00, stops at Santa Justa station and ends 40 minutes later beside the river at Plaza de Armas, for about $4.50.
Granada's airport sees roughly a tenth of that traffic. The list is short enough to read aloud: Madrid, Barcelona, Paris Orly, Amsterdam, London Luton and some domestic hops. The Alsa bus runs about ten times a day, takes around 45 minutes and costs about $3.50. Miss the last one and it is a $35 taxi. Anyone flying out for work every month should stop here and take this seriously, since most trips from Granada will begin with a connection.
The first hour with a suitcase
Seville is flat. From Plaza de Armas you can roll your bag along the Guadalquivir, cross the Isabel II bridge into Triana, or head up to the Alameda, and the Giralda keeps you oriented. By the time you have dropped your things you will have noticed the orange trees along the streets, whose bitter fruit gets shipped to Britain for marmalade. Sevici docks and the short central tram mean you will rarely need a car. It is a city of nearly 700,000 that behaves like a much smaller one.
Granada starts easily and then tilts. Plaza Nueva is a fine place to begin, and the Carrera del Darro runs beside the little river with the Alhambra straight overhead. But if you booked the flat everyone wants, in a carmen in the Albaicín, your taxi will often stop short of the door, because many lanes are closed to cars, and you will finish the trip on foot and uphill. Do it anyway, then climb to the Mirador de San Nicolás at dusk. The Nasrid palaces and the Generalife stand across the valley with the Sierra Nevada behind them, and we know of no better first evening in Spain. Order a drink on the way down and a plate of food will come with it, free, as it usually does here.
The first hour in July and in January
Everyone warns you about Seville's heat, and rightly: some 60 days a year pass 35°C, and from about two until seven in summer the streets are empty. What fewer people mention is that Granada is only a degree cooler at its July peak. Its 738 metres help after dark, when the nights are more bearable. They do not help at four in the afternoon.
The altitude bites in the other direction. A Granada winter brings cold nights and the occasional frost, though you are also close to the ski slopes that hosted the 1996 world championships. Seville's January is the reason people forgive its August.
What the two would charge you
A month in Seville comes to about $2,400 by our estimate, and a month in Granada about $1,800. Local rents differ by much less, about $550 against $410 for a one-bedroom on a new lease, so much of the saving depends on not paying a foreigner's premium for a view. The rest comes from those free plates and from a city of 233,000 with some 47,000 university students, whose prices are set accordingly. The same Spanish rules apply to your stay in both.
So weigh your flights first. Monthly travel, or clients who expect you in person, means Seville. Without those, we would choose Granada for a year and pay for the odd connection with what it saves.
The cheapest way to find out is to use both doors. Fly into Seville, stay a week, take the three-hour bus across Andalusia, stay another week, and fly out of Granada. By the second airport you will know which suitcase walk you could face again.