Five years explain most of what you will notice about these two places. Between 1948 and 1953 one of them lost about a tenth of its people and the other took in more people than it could hold. The stone walls and silences of Jeju come from that time, and so do the staircases and the noodles of Busan. A remote worker does not need the history to rent a flat, but it tells you what kind of place you are renting in.
Jeju in 1948
On 3 April 1948 an uprising began on the island, and the suppression that followed killed somewhere between 14,000 and 30,000 people, most of them at the hands of security forces. About 230 of the island's 400 villages were burned, and only 170 remained afterwards. Some 40,000 people fled to Japan. For almost fifty years, simply talking about it could get you beaten or jailed. A president apologised in 2003, and the Jeju 4.3 Peace Park opened in Bonggae-dong in 2008.
You will feel the result without being told, once you know to look. Jeju Island today has about 666,000 people, spread thinly around one volcano, and a culture that is unusually its own: an endangered language, shaman rites, and the haenyeo, the women who dive without tanks, of whom about 4,500 were still active in 2014, most over 60. The Olle trails run 437 kilometres through villages walled in black basalt laid without mortar. They are lovely, and some of the green gaps between them were once villages too.
You will meet few foreigners and little English. Nor will you get far without a rental car, at $28 to $42 a day, since the $1 city buses are slow. For a person who wants to work in the morning and walk alone through the afternoon, nothing else in Korea comes close.
Busan from 1950
When the North Korean army overran most of the peninsula in 1950, it never took Busan, so the country came to it. The city was the provisional capital for 1,023 days, with the president in a former governor's residence that is now a museum. About half a million refugees were reported there by early 1951. By 1960 more than a million people were living in a city with capacity for about 250,000, and mountains cover roughly 70 percent of its land. So people built upward.
That is why this seaside city looks the way it does. Fifteen minutes uphill from Busan Station, the 168 steep steps of Choryang were once the fastest way home, and there is now a small monorail for older residents. In Uam-dong, refugees partitioned an old livestock quarantine shed into homes. Gamcheon, the pastel village every visitor photographs, is a slightly different story: its first houses are older, and it grew in 1955 when about 800 families of a religious community arrived. Artists came in 2009.
You eat the same history at lunch. Milmyeon is cold noodle soup remade in wheat flour by wartime refugees. Dwaeji gukbap, a pork and rice soup, dates from the same years. Gukje Market, near Nampo station, sits where displaced people set up stalls selling whatever they could find, and it still trades in kitchenware and tools.
A city built by arrivals is easier to arrive in. You can go from Haeundae to Seomyeon on a four-line metro for $1 to $1.50, and work from Pathfinder, a coworking chain with hot desks at about $63 a month. There is a beach at the end of your train line, and Seoul is a little over two hours by the fastest KTX. You will still want Korean when you look for a flat.
What is the same
Korea's workation visa treats them alike. Both lie outside the Seoul region, so the income test starts at the lower end, $3,030 a month for under-35s, and our visa page sets out how it rises with age. The monthly bill is also close, at about $2,200 on Jeju and $2,400 in Busan on our estimate, though a month of that rental car would swamp the difference. Summer is wet in both, with more than 270 millimetres in the worst month. Busan is colder on a January night, near freezing against about 4°C on the island.
Live in Busan. It has the trains, the food and the other people, and you can compare it with the capital on our Seoul and Busan page. Then give Jeju a week at the start of April, when the island holds its memorial at the Peace Park, and walk an Olle route afterwards. You will look at those walls differently.