The word dolmuş means something close to "stuffed", a fair description of the shared minibuses that have carried Turkey around since 1929. A ride costs about 50 cents in Fethiye. Follow one in each of these towns and you have the whole decision, because almost nothing else separates them. January afternoons reach 15°C in Antalya and 16°C in Fethiye, and our estimate of a month is the same to the dollar: $1,800 in Antalya, $1,800 in Fethiye.
Where the minibus goes
In Fethiye the dolmuş is the network. The bazaar, the fish market and the marina are all within a 15 or 20 minute walk of a central flat, and everything else, from the long shingle front at Çalış to the protected Blue Lagoon at Ölüdeniz 14 kilometres south, hangs off a few minibus routes. You will soon have two or three that you know by heart, and paragliders drifting down from Babadağ at the end of one of them. The town is young, too, in a physical sense: the earthquakes of 1957 wrecked it, so almost everything you see below the rock tombs was rebuilt under rules we cover in our guide to buying there.
In Antalya the dolmuş is one layer among several. A city of about 1.5 million also has buses, a tram along the boulevard, and the AntRay light rail running out to the airport. You could reasonably pick a flat in Konyaaltı, with its 7 kilometres of pebble beach under the Taurus Mountains, or in plain, busy Muratpaşa, purely for which line it sits on. The minibus takes you across a real city with real variety, and you will spend more of your day getting about.
Where it stops
The last stop is the airport, and that is what decides this for most people. Antalya's handled 39 million passengers in 2025. Dalaman, your airport in Fethiye, handled 5.6 million from a site 45 to 50 kilometres away, reached by a shuttle at about $3 to $4, and a long list of its routes are marked seasonal. You will still get to Istanbul in the winter. Getting directly to much of Europe in February is another matter, and we would check the actual schedule for your own city before you commit.
Antalya's success brings one risk that a smaller town may spare you. Around 120,000 foreigners live there, and Turkey stops issuing residence permits for a neighbourhood once foreigners pass 20 percent of its residents. Ask about the exact address before you sign for a year.
Six months or twelve
We would pick Fethiye for a half-year stay in spring or autumn, when the Lycian Way, which begins just above town at Ovacık, is at its best. For twelve months, or for any job that puts you on planes, take Antalya, and go out to the other end of that same path at weekends. Before signing either lease, spend a week in each without a car, using only what stops at the end of the street.