Live in Lisbon. Go to Ericeira on weekends, or for a month in the autumn, and keep your lease in the city. That is our answer for nearly everyone who is weighing up these two, and there is a good case against it.
The case for Ericeira
Start with the money. We put a month at about $2,200 in Ericeira and about $3,500 in Lisbon, and $1,300 a month is $15,600 a year. Nearly all of it is the flat. Local tenants on a new lease pay about $560 for a one-bedroom in Ericeira and about $890 in Lisbon, while food, phone and everything else come out the same in both.
Then there is what you get for less. Whitewashed houses with blue trim sit on a cliff above Praia dos Pescadores, the small beach where Portugal's last king left his country for good in October 1910. Along about five kilometres of coast are the breaks that made this Europe's first World Surfing Reserve: Ribeira d'Ilhas, which hosts professional contests, Coxos, which you should stay out of until you are very good, and gentler water at Foz do Lizandro. Desks are there too, at The Salt Studio and Kelp, with fast connections and people who will notice when you skip a morning. And when Lisbon reaches 28°C in July, you are sitting in a sea breeze at 23°C. A short drive inland, the palace at Mafra keeps 36,000 old books in a rococo library, guarded from insects by a colony of bats.
All of that is true, and Lisbon's centre in August is no reward for your higher rent.
Why we still say Lisbon
The trouble is what a place this size does to the other days. Ericeira has only about 10,000 people. You can walk across its centre in minutes, and by your second month you have eaten at all the fish restaurants and seen the same faces at the same bar. No train comes here. Your link is Carris Metropolitana line 2740, which takes about 80 minutes and 46 stops to reach Campo Grande, on the north side of Lisbon, where you change to the metro. With luggage, door to door from the airport, allow around two hours. That is fine for a planned trip. It is not fine for dinner, for a concert or for the friend who says "come over tonight", and those things are what the extra money pays for in Lisbon: Second Home's plant-filled space inside the Mercado da Ribeira, a red line straight to the terminal, Alfama and Príncipe Real and Cais do Sodré on an ordinary evening. Our Lisbon guide has the rest.
The calendar works against Ericeira too. The surf is best from October to May, when the sky is at its worst: December brings over 100 millimetres of rain and highs of 16°C, and the village has gone quiet. You arrive for the waves and you get them, along with long dark evenings. Lisbon in those months is at least busy indoors.
Who should ignore all this
A serious surfer should. That saving of $15,600 is real, an 80-minute bus means little to someone who has no reason to go to the city, and no amount of Lisbon can replace paddling out at Ribeira d'Ilhas before your first call. So should anyone with a book to finish who truly wants fewer evenings out.
The test is simple, and you can do it from your sofa. Count how many mornings last month you would truly have been in the water by eight. Three a week earns you Ericeira. Anything less, keep the flat in Lisbon and take the bus when the swell looks good.