Both towns have a Playa de los Muertos, a Beach of the Dead, and the two beaches tell you most of what you need to know. In Puerto Vallarta it is the busiest strip in the old town, with rented palapas, a modern pier and a crowd that stays till late. In Sayulita you reach it on a dirt road through the cemetery, and the story goes that the beach belongs to the dead after sunset. Walk the streets behind each one before you decide.
Up Basilio Badillo
Start on the pier in Puerto Vallarta, finished in 2013 to replace an older wooden one, with a metal structure in the middle shaped like a ship's sail. Turn your back on Banderas Bay and walk inland, and you cross Olas Altas a block up, with its coffee shops and restaurants. Then comes Basilio Badillo, where the day could arrange itself: yoga on a third floor at number 325, breakfast at Café de Olla, a look round Galería Dante in its old hacienda. Takos Panchos starts cutting al pastor at about six. At the Constitución corner, a local bus will take you south to Mismaloya for about 50 cents.
A few blocks north, the Cuale river cuts the neighbourhood off from Centro. Vallarta Cowork sits near it, with fibre and round-the-clock access. Isla Cuale, the narrow island in the river, turns quiet upstream, with galleries, sunning cats and a statue of John Huston. Over the bridge, the Malecón runs along the water, past Bustamante sculptures, with half the town out on it on a Sunday evening. This is the centre of the city's gay scene, one of the best known in Mexico, and you will hear it at night. It is also changing, with many of the old houses already replaced by condominiums, and a one-bedroom here runs from about $1,150 to $1,850.
Puerto Vallarta has 224,000 people, and everything you will eventually need is somewhere along that bus route.
Round the plaza in Sayulita
Sayulita counted 3,390 people in the 2020 census, and its centre is a couple of blocks across. Calle Delfines is the main drag. Huichol artisans sell beadwork in the plaza every day, the grocers are just off it, and Avenida Revolución has several good places to eat. The cobbles are uneven and slippery after rain, so a short walk can feel like a small project, and you could cross the whole town between one call and the next. Surfers have been coming since the 1960s, when a new highway from Vallarta arrived. The wave out front has a sandy bottom and stays small from January to March, which is why so many people learn on it.
You will work at Sayulita CoWork, three blocks from the sand, because it is the only dedicated space in town. It does have fibre with battery backup, so calls are fine. By the second week you will know most of the people there, and for some that is the whole appeal.
Three things the walk does not show
The clock. Sayulita is in Nayarit, but its municipality, Bahía de Banderas, moved to Central time in 2010, so the two towns keep the same hours despite the state line.
The sea. In April 2025 Mexico's health regulator flagged Sayulita's beach for enterococci, a marker of sewage. A hotel spill and a detached pipe at the treatment plant were blamed and repaired, and a local nonprofit now tests independently. Do not swim near the river mouth after a storm, and look up the latest result first.
February 2026. When Mexican forces killed the cartel leader known as El Mencho on 22 February, Puerto Vallarta was hit harder than anywhere else. Vehicles burned on the main roads, people were told to shelter in place, and flights were cancelled. Airports and hotels were working normally again within about a week. Sayulita shares that airport and that highway, so moving up the coast does not take you out of the same event. Keep a week's cash and water on hand in either town.
Which to rent
We put both at about $2,200 a month, so the village gives you no discount for having less in it. For that reason we would live in the Zona Romántica from November to April and treat Sayulita as the place you go. The Compostela bus leaves from the pedestrian bridge at the airport every ten minutes and costs about $3. It stops whenever anyone asks and can take two hours, so go on a Tuesday, take a board lesson, and stay the night only when you find you do not want to come back.