From Rizal Boulevard you can see Cebu across the water. It looks close, and it is: the boat from Sibulan, just up the coast, crosses to Liloan in about 20 minutes. Then you get off and find that Cebu City is still 133 kilometres and three to four hours away by bus, up the whole length of the island. Almost everything about this choice is like that, closer than it looks in one way and further in another.
Take the sea. The big city on the famous island barely touches it in daily life: IT Park is towers and fibre, the beaches are on Mactan, and the sardines at Moalboal are 105 kilometres from your desk. The small town has its whole social life on a seafront, in old sugar mansions turned into bars and coffee shops, with a reef you can reach before lunch. Boats leave for Apo Island from Malatapay, about 30 kilometres south, and take half an hour. That reef is one of the great success stories of Philippine conservation. In 1982 Angel Alcala, a marine scientist at Dumaguete's Silliman University, persuaded the island's fishermen to protect a stretch of it, after about three years of talks. More than 650 fish species have since been recorded, and over 60 sea turtles. On this measure, Dumaguete is much the richer place, and it fits 142,000 people into 34 square kilometres, so your daily errands stay short, at the cost of a tricycle fare.
Now take power. Dumaguete's electricity comes from the geothermal plant in Valencia, the next town. Yet brownouts and outages are more common here than in the larger cities. Cebu, for all its traffic and bad air on main roads, is where a night-shift industry insists on keeping the internet up, and fast apartment fibre is common around IT Park. A power station next door is no help on a client call when the line drops.
Price, age and leaving
You might expect the quiet town to be far cheaper. It is not: we put a month at about $1,300, compared with $1,500 in Cebu. A gap of $200 will not settle the question, and if you dive twice a month, the bus fares and overnight stays you would spend reaching Moalboal from Cebu could close most of it. Nor is the small town only a retirement home, despite its 2018 title as the country's best place to retire. Silliman, founded in 1901, fills its streets with students, so the town is younger than its reputation. You will be surrounded by English speakers in either place.
Getting away does favour Cebu in the most literal sense: Dumaguete's little airport has daily flights to Manila and Cebu, so for most international trips you go through the place you decided against.
Our lean is towards Dumaguete for anyone whose work tolerates an occasional outage, with a good power bank and a second SIM on the desk. Those on calls all day should stay in Cebu and cross on long weekends, which is also how we would test the idea: a few days on the boulevard, then a boat out to Apo.